What rolling a put down and out nets — and what assignment would actually cost you.
The put you have open
The put you'd sell instead
When a put you sold goes in the money, you have three choices: take the assignment, close for a loss, or roll — buy this one back and sell another, usually further out and often at a lower strike. Rolling is the only one of the three that keeps the cycle alive, which is why it is tempting. It is also the only one that can be repeated indefinitely while the position quietly gets worse.
Down and out on two contracts
Two $50 puts sold for $120 each are now $300 each to close, 4 days left.
Roll to the $47, 39 days out, for $250 each. Fees $4.
Net credit: $500 − $600 − $4 = −$104. A debit.
But the strike came down $3, and net cost if assigned is now $46.32 a share.
That is the real trade: $104 and 35 extra days, in exchange for $3 less exposure.
A debit roll is not automatically a bad roll
Paying to move a strike further from the money is often the right call — you are buying protection, not income. What matters is that you can see you are paying, and how much. The calculator will not annualise a debit, because there is no rate on money going out.
The wheel assumes you are willing to own the stock. If that is still true, assignment is not a failure — it is the next step, and it stops you paying to postpone something you were prepared for.
$60 is capital locked at a terrible rate.Related: rolling for the judgement, and the CSP take-profit calculator for the opposite situation — a put that is winning and might be worth closing early.
Rolling
Buying back and re-selling to buy time — and the honest test for whether it's helping.
Educational only
These figures come from the numbers you enter and standard options arithmetic. Nothing here is investment, financial, or tax advice, and a good-looking return says nothing about whether the underlying stock is a good idea.
Cash-Secured Put Calculator
Collateral, return on capital, annualized yield and breakeven for a put you're thinking about selling.
Covered Call Calculator
Premium yield, what you make if the shares get called away, and where your basis actually sits.
LEAPS Calculator
Breakeven, how much capital a long-dated call saves against shares, and what you're paying for time.
Poor Man's Covered Call Calculator
Net debit, strike width, and whether the setup clears the one rule that decides if a PMCC can work.
CSP Take-Profit Calculator
Whether closing at 25/50/75% actually beats holding — and the last day it still does.
Covered Call Take-Profit Calculator
Whether buying the call back early beats holding — and the last day it still does.
Covered Call Roll Calculator
What a roll really nets after the buyback — and whether the new strike still clears your basis.